The Best Bakeries Around Sarasota, Florida

Want to know the Best Bakeries Around Sarasota, Florida? Well..I put it together for you. Sarasota, Florida is growing fast, and you can feel it everywhere you go. With new neighborhoods like Lakewood Ranch, Wellen Park, and Skye Ranch expanding, plus so many new construction communities throughout Palmer Ranch, Venice, and Nokomis, Sarasota is quickly becoming one of the most sought-after places to live on Florida’s Gulf Coast. As more people move in, the local lifestyle is thriving — and that includes a major boom in the food area. Bakeries around Sarasota are busier than ever, becoming go-to spots for residents who love getting together, meeting friends, and enjoying great coffee and pastries.

The Best Bakeries Around Sarasota 

I created a list for you, and you will want these spots saved to your Google Maps ASAP. From flaky croissants to wild, over-the-top donuts, and yummy breads. And bonus: many of these bakeries are located near some of Sarasota’s most charming neighborhoods — perfect if you are house hunting and need a snack break.

Love it!

Breville Barista Express Espresso Machine

$696.49

Great coffee machine to make your morning coffee 🙂

Buy Now

As an Amazon Associate I earn a commission from qualifying purchases, at no additional cost to you.

04/25/2025 08:50 pm GMT

🍞 Bakery Breakdown: Quick Comparison

Morton’s Gourmet Market Bakery

📍 Southside Village, Sarasota

If you’re searching for best bakeries near Southside Village Sarasota, Morton’s Gourmet Market Bakery needs to be at the top of your list. It’s technically a market, but their bakery is a little piece of heaven. Almond croissants, mini lemon tarts, fresh loaves — it’s gourmet without feeling fussy.

Pet-friendly: Small patio seating outside, pups welcome! 🐾

Neighborhood Vibes: Southside Village is one of Sarasota’s most walkable, charming areas with historic homes, tree-lined streets, and Sarasota Memorial Hospital just a block away.

Check my blog post called Best Restaurants You Must Visit in Sarasota, Florida

Five-O Donut Co.

📍 Downtown Sarasota & South Trail

If you’re craving best donut shops Sarasota, Five-O is your jam. They whip up wild flavors like bacon maple, cookie monster, and cinnamon toast crunch. Expect lines (and zero regrets).

Pet-friendly: Downtown location is super dog-friendly! 🐶 Outdoor benches and water bowls available.

Neighborhood Vibes: Walkable downtown living, close to Rosemary District and Gillespie Park — perfect for those looking at condos, lofts, or colorful historic bungalows.

Rendez-Vous French Bakery

📍 Clark Road, Sarasota

For authentic French bakeries Sarasota, Rendez-Vous will make you forget you’re in Florida. Their croissants are buttery and flaky perfection, and their baguettes are honestly better than some I had in Paris.

Pet-friendly: Limited outdoor seating, but grab-and-go works great for a beach or park day.

Neighborhood Vibes: Gulf Gate Estates is a hidden gem! Affordable homes, close to Siesta Key, and super popular for first-time buyers and snowbirds.

OfKors Bakery

📍 Gulf Gate, Sarasota

If you’re Googling European bakeries Sarasota, this Ukrainian-owned gem will steal your heart (and stomach). Think cinnamon buns, poppyseed rolls, and hearty breads that taste like they’re made with love.

Pet-friendly: Takeout only — but grab a pastry and head to Gulf Gate Library Park nearby for a doggy date!

Neighborhood Vibes: Gulf Gate is quirky, eclectic, and walkable. Tons of bars, shops, and even a vintage record store vibe.

Der Dutchman Bakery

📍 Pinecraft, Sarasota

This is where you go for Amish bakeries Sarasota vibes. Giant pies, cinnamon rolls bigger than your head, fry pies filled with every fruity goodness imaginable — Der Dutchman is a must-visit (and you’ll leave with a bag full of goodies).

Pet-friendly: Sadly, no — but their food is so good, you’ll forgive them.

Neighborhood Vibes: Pinecraft is famous for its Amish and Mennonite community. It’s a unique, peaceful part of Sarasota with charming, simple living.

Check Der Dutchmen Bakery website here.

The Artisan Cheese Company

📍 Downtown Sarasota

Technically a cheese shop, but lowkey one of the best places for artisan bread Sarasota. Their local partnerships with small bakeries mean you’ll find sourdoughs, olive loaves, and baguettes that are next-level delicious.

Pet-friendly: Yes, downtown location is very dog-welcoming. 🐾

Neighborhood Vibes: Right by Burns Court and Laurel Park — two of the most historic, artsy residential areas in Sarasota.

Here is the Artisan Cheese Company‘s website.

Breville Loaf Bread Maker Machine

$299.95

Or make yourown fresh yummy bread!

Buy Now

As an Amazon Associate I earn a commission from qualifying purchases, at no additional cost to you.

04/25/2025 08:50 pm GMT

✨ Bonus Sarasota Bakery Map:

Neighborhoods and The Best Bakeries Around Sarasota, Florida

Whether you are daydreaming about downtown condos, cozy Gulf Gate cottages, or beachy bungalows near Siesta Key, trust me — you’ll never be far from a fresh loaf, a fluffy donut, or a flaky croissant.

So, next time you’re touring homes or exploring Sarasota, don’t forget to add a bakery stop (or three) to your plans. Your future self will thank you. 🥐🏡🍰

Why Rendez-Vous French Bakery is One of My Favorite Spots in Sarasota

When people ask me where I like to meet up with friends for a quick coffee and something sweet, my first answer is almost always Rendez-Vous French Bakery. There is just something special about it. It’s one of those places that feels like a little slice of Europe tucked right into Sarasota — and once you go once, you totally get it.

I love Rendez-Vous because it’s so easy and convenient. Located right off Clark Road near the Gulf Gate area, it’s never out of the way, whether I’m showing homes nearby, running errands, or just looking for a spot to catch up with friends. Seriously, even if I didn’t have plans, I’d probably invent a reason to swing by.

Now, full honesty — Rendez-Vous does get busy. Especially on weekends or right around brunch time, the line can sometimes stretch out the door. But you know what? I actually love that. It feels like a sign that you’re in the right place. It’s that everybody’s-here-for-the-good-stuff kind of vibe that somehow makes your coffee and croissant taste even better. Plus, the team there is very efficient, and it always feels worth the short wait.

What I really love is the atmosphere. It’s relaxed but lively — the kind of spot where you’ll see people having deep conversations over lattes, parents grabbing pastries for kids in soccer uniforms, and friends laughing over second (or third) cappuccinos. You can totally show up in yoga pants or jeans and feel right at home. It’s just easy, welcoming, and real.

The food, of course, is incredible. Their croissants are the real deal — buttery, flaky, and just the right amount of chewy inside. Their almond croissants are probably my favorite. And don’t even get me started on their baguettes. Everything tastes fresh, handmade, and tasty.

Another reason I love meeting people at Rendez-Vous? The location is very convenient. If we feel like hanging out longer, Gulf Gate shops and even Siesta Key are just a short drive away.

Another great place I forgot to mention is Bread Bandits. If you are a bread lover, Bread Bandits is a must-visit in Sarasota. They specialize in hand-crafted, small-batch breads that are truly next level — think crusty sourdough loaves, rustic baguettes, and perfectly soft sandwich breads. Everything they make is baked with high-quality ingredients and serious attention to detail, giving each loaf that authentic, artisanal feel you usually only find in big city bakeries. Bread Bandits is known for their long fermentation process. Love visiting this place. Also their pastries are one of the best pastries in Sarasota. So, this concludes this blog post about the best bakeries around Sarasota, Florida.

If you haven’t been in these places yet, do yourself a favor and go — but fair warning, you might end up just as obsessed as I am.

Thanks for reading!